Monday 23 December 2013

by Chua Zi, Class of 2014, Form 4 Science 1



Having seen both An Unexpected Journey and The Desolation of Smaug several times — before I’d read the book and after — this is clearly Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit, not Tolkien’s.

In its entirety, The Hobbit, unlike its sequel, was merely a serial that Professor J.R.R. Tolkien initially wrote to read to his three sons. After being persuaded by his colleagues at Oxford and a publishing company, he eventually completed it. 

It’s about a well-to-do hobbit - little people about half our height - named Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman), who, thanks to a wizard named Gandalf (Ian McKellen), finds thirteen dwarves at his doorstep one day. He then accompanies them on a long adventure to recover the treasures of the dwarves’ ancestors. Along the way they encounter trolls, a dragon, orcs, elves, men, all the while singing rhymes and riddling their way out of trouble.

You don't need to read the Lord of The Rings trilogy to love Jackson’s movie adaptations enough to feel quite excited to see more. So from the first film of The Hobbit, it’s obvious why Jackson would try to adapt Tolkien’s classic children’s book into an epic on the scale of LoTR.

But from the second, not only was it nowhere close, but it seemed like he was aiming to imitate or top his past work and was failing at it. Jackson’s attempted adventure epic is a lot more ‘grown-up’ and tried to be a much darker tale than it actually is. It tried.

Naturally, the films should lack the structure they would have if the book was only split into two parts but really, it can easily be read as three. And considering the high production values demanded by this franchise — shooting in 3D, at 48 frames per second, the sweeping CGI landscapes, and keeping track of 13 dwarves — it's a wise decision. Even so, the tedious length of each film is uncalled for and due, in part, to the unnecessary additional material which are especially prevalent in this one.

We've reached a faster-paced part of the story where Bilbo and company are approaching the Lonely Mountain to face the dragon, Smaug (voiced by Benedict Cumberbatch), that guards it. 

Radagast is still being driven by bunnies, and Bard the Bowman is now a lowly bargeman, giving leeway to write new scenes only to reach the same conclusion 10 minutes later. Just as Thorin Oakenshield’s ‘death’ was written as a new denouement for the first film, a time-stalling action plan was written for the dwarves to carry out in hopes of defeating Smaug in the second one, only for him to emerge unscathed in the end anyway.

Orlando Bloom was also brought back to set as the silver-haired Wood-elf Legolas, only to be stuck in long choreographies of fight scenes. At first sight, I think back to the innate elven grace of the Legolas of LoTR, then the fighting starts to get a little tired. Scenes are written so he can swoop in and perform a dance of decapitating orcs except it’s less like So You Think You Can Dance and more like Dance Moms.

The lack of female characters always seems to be an issue whenever Tolkien’s works are being discussed. Although I don’t see the need for a main female character in The Hobbit, Jackson’s decision to write in the Wood-elf Tauriel (Evangeline Lilly), who is almost as cool as Legolas, is a welcome change.



Alas, even the Middle Earth franchise couldn’t escape from the parasitic plot device that claimed the first Hunger Games movie: a love triangle. One of the reasons why the film fell short, even before I had read the book, is that it is cliched. Likely a half hour of footage was added to entertain the love triangle between Legolas, Tauriel and the young dwarf Kili. Due diligence was put into writing a string of scenes to develop her relationship with the dwarf, which seems all too reminiscent of a fanfic headcanon. The lesson here is: trying to appeal to wider audiences does not justify lazy writing.

Peter Jackson does still have a love and awareness of Tolkien. In the films, he expands on what is going on in the background of our little adventure story, in the wider Middle Earth, drawing from Tolkien’s other works about this fantasy world’s history.

Yet, the real strength of the films lies in the small interactions. These are the scenes where you catch a glimpse of the relationships between the characters or the different races. The emphasis on a more ignorant Master of Lake-Town (Stephen Fry) showed the unbalanced relationship between the ruler of men and the men themselves like Bard. That provided a relatable view in a world as far-removed from our own as Middle Earth. It was also interesting to see how coldly Thorin (Richard Armitage), the king of dwarves was treated by Thranduil (Lee Pace), the Elvenking, reflecting the Wood-elves’ aversion to interfering in foreign affairs.


If there’s one thing these films did right, it is casting Martin Freeman as Bilbo Baggins because he brings the warmth and lightheartedness that is what these films should embody. It is the iconic scenes like the riddles in the dark between Bilbo and Gollum (Andy Serkis) in the previous film, and the banter between Smaug and Bilbo in the echoing halls of Erebor in this one that are memorable. Sadly, in losing track of the spirit of the story, the film constantly loses track of the main character in a bout of fight scenes and backstory.

I still would take a hobbit film over another blockbuster almost every time. As Laura Hudson of WIRED admits,“Sometimes when you really love something, all you want is more, even if it’s less.”

Despite being riddled by a banal love story and blatantly overdone fight scenes, the film is decent if your attention span can take it. I’m sure the cast and crew of The Hobbit are big fans of Tolkien or are just having a lot of fun making these movies. Middle Earth still looks breathtaking through Jackson’s lenses, even being as CGI-ridden as ever. Smaug really does live up to his name as the Chiefest and Greatest of Calamities.

However, while there is an inherent humour in the characters and especially the dwarves written by Tolkien, Jackson misses it and forces it. That is what these films are — forced. It is a shame that Middle Earth missed its chance to showcase the charm that endeared people like me to the world those many years ago.

Rating: 3.7/5
by Anonymous 22:44 34 comments | in , , ,

34 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I didn't like Hobbit that much. The Lord of The Rings is way better. My colleague at http://hitthegrade.com/ is a huge Tolkien fan and I think he would like to see this post and make some comments about the movie. Thanks a lot for posting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for sharing the facts. You truly impressed me by this post of yours harley quinn jacket. And what exactly is additional commendable will be the authenticity in the content material.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you. The information that you have provided is very helpful Scholarship essay writing service.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all folks you actually recognize what you are speaking about! Bookmarked

    clipping path service|Photo Retouching services|Vector Tracing

    ReplyDelete
  6. Deontay Wilder vs Luis Ortiz live
    Everything you need to know about Deontay Wilder vs Luis Ortiz. Fight news, tape, ringwalk time, TV channel, streams, latest odds & ticket details.
    Ortiz Wilder 2 live stream

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fedor Emelianenko: Bellator 208 Live Stream, TV Channel, Time ... fight, he beat Quinton Jackson in the opening round of the heavyweight ...
    Jackson vs Fedor online free

    ReplyDelete
  8. I would suggest you to add related images in this. Check this guide by 4Hub and reduce your work.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Fedor Emelianenko: Bellator 208 Live Stream, TV Channel, Time ... fight, he beat Quinton Jackson in the opening round of the heavyweight ... Sonic the Hedgehog Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  10. Bentang alam CGI, dan catat 13 kurcaci - ini keputusan yang bijak. Meski begitu, panjang membosankan dari setiap situs prediksi bola film tidak pantas untuk dan karena, sebagian, dengan tambahan yang tidak perlu

    ReplyDelete
  11. I always found very much interesting content on your posts. keep posting, thanks for sharing us and giving us your precious time. "
    Cyberpunk 2077 Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  12. Kami telah mencapai bagian yang lebih cepat dari kisah di mana Bilbo dan teman-temannya slot deposit pulsa

    ReplyDelete
  13. Sometimes, students are left to have a choicewhat topic to choose once they will have to write a researh paper. Our huge list of the research topic ideas for college is something what would be useful for many students if they lack of ideas. If it happened for you to be in similar situation, our guidelines and ideas will help you a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  14. One of the best alternatives in treating different kinds of pain is cannabidiol or CBD for short. Because of its multitude of benefits, it has gained so much popularity that more medical professionals have turned their attention to the study of its use and advantages. Among its benefits is for pain, and thus, me and my Health Canal Team have covered another article that tackles all the best CBD oils for pain as well as other details on how you can safely use any of them. But before we begin, let's go over the factors you need to consider in choosing the best CBD oil. Buy CBD Oils For Sale

    ReplyDelete
  15. If you want to buy Avon online then you need to visit the official Avon website. It's easy but there are a few steps you need to take so that you can make the most out of your time and money. In this article I will give you the most important step of how to buy Avon online.Shop sales Just as the online world continues to grow, many retail stores like Avon offer you a multitude of ways of shopping both online and offline. The most basic way is to visit the store in person and then purchase their merchandise. If you have the time and patience, you could also order a few items and pay for it at the store and when you get home, they will deliver it to your door for you. This is the easiest and cheapest way to shop for your cosmetics. However, many people don't have the time or patience to drive to a store, pick up a few items and then wait until the next day to deliver them to the doorstep. You should avoid stores like that if you want to save a lot of money and time, since they really only make money from you by taking a percentage of what you pay for their products. More Details Here View Avon brochure online

    ReplyDelete
  16. In the early days of Avon, the only way to find out about new products and deals was to go to their online store. These days, you can use your computer and an internet connection to order your favorite product. Avon now offers its own website, AvonAnew, and it has everything you need to know about Avon. They even have a feature where you can track your shopping to see how much your discount has increased over time. This is a great way to make sure that you do not end up buying something that will disappoint you. Click Here & Get More buy Avon Anew online

    ReplyDelete
  17. When you want to shop for Avon in your local store or online for beauty products, there are many options. Shopping Avon at your local store gives you more choices than just makeup and skin care products. You also have access to products such as fragrances, hair care products, health and beauty products, and so much more. But if you want to shop Avon and get access to products from all over the world, then you need to purchase the products online. By doing this, you have access to products from all over the world including countries in Asia. This is why people who live in different parts of the world to buy products from these stores in order to save money and enjoy the convenience of shopping online. Avon has even taken it to the next level and has created a site called Makeup Catalog Online. More Details Avon Beauty with Carrie

    ReplyDelete

  18. Thank you for the information, as we know one image can say thousand words. This is the best way / method to engage people and convert them!NY Tourism

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you found any common issue like installation error, connectivity error. company file issue, PDF related error and printing issues in your Quickbooks software, you can download Quickbooks Tool Hub to fix all issues. This tool is the compilation of all tools in one application.
    Download Quickbooks tool hub

    ReplyDelete
  20. The person who created this post it was a great human .. Thank you for sharing this amazing one post. Yellowstone Jacket Collection

    ReplyDelete
  21. All Swords are amazing they remember us the past decades where the man took the swords. I have bought it from amazon and everything is perfect about it. American Gods Movie Jacket Collection

    ReplyDelete
  22. I also really love this movie and this is the time when the film could be so interested as a book. The film series of Hobbit is awesome and should be watched by everyone, it is like timeless classic and you can read my personal movie review essay example https://bestwritingservice.com/essays/Technology/Dependence-on-Technology.html on this film where I wrote my opinion and thoughts concerning this film, why it should be watched by everyone, the sign hidden inside the plot and many others. You can also read many other reviews which I write on the basis of some films or books.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Slovakia is considered a large state due to its total area. Its total area is 49,035 km² (about 18,932 mi²). The continental shelf of Slovakia is approximately 0 km². Slovakia is located in Europe. Europe is a continent whose borders date back to the period of antiquity. European countries include, but are not limited to, the United Kingdom, Italy, Germany, Switzerland, Luxembourg, Malta and the Vatican. Slovakia has 5 neighboring countries. Its neighbors are Austria, Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Ukraine. Slovakia is a landlocked country. The average height of Slovakia is 458 m (1503 ft). http://www.confiduss.com/en/jurisdictions/slovakia/infrastructure/

    ReplyDelete
  24. Happy New Years Around the World 2022, In 2022 many Countries Mark there 10th year Commemorate observance of Christmas. Happy new year Around the World 2022

    ReplyDelete

  25. تعتبر مهمة تنظيف المنزل من المهام اليومية التي تلقى على عاتق كلّ ربة منزل، حيث إنّ تنظيف الغرف، والمطبخ، والأفنية الخارجية، والحمامات يتطلب وقتاً طويلاً وجهداً مضاعفاً للاستمتاع بشعور النظافة طوال الوقت، ولم تعد مهمة تنظيف المنزل صعبةً على ربة البيت وذلك لامتلاكها أدوات كهربائية تعينها على أداء جزء كبير من الأعمال المنزلية، الأمر الذي خفف العبء الكبير عنها، وسنذكر في هذا المقال طرقاً سهلة لتنظيف وترتيب المنزل بشكل عملي وبسيط، وتساعد على إنجاز الأعمال بطريقة سلسة، وبجهد أقل.
    شركة تنظيف منازل بأبها
    تتعرض العديد من المنازل للضرر والانهيار نتيجة العديد من العوامل التي تواجهها ، وحتى لو لم نستسلم لهذه الأضرار ، فقد توصلنا إلى طريقة لمعالجة هذه المشاكل ، وأهمها الترميم ، و ونقصد بذلك الأماكن المتضررة في المباني سواء كانت أسقف أو حوائط حدثت فيها الكثير من الخدوش أو الشقوق أو الأعطال. التي تؤثر على نظام السباكة والأنابيب والكهرباء ، أو تلف الأرضيات والسيراميك ، أو تغيير في الدهانات والديكورات ، وكل ذلك يمكن معالجته من خلال عملية ترميم المنازل.
    مكافحة حشرات المنزل بالنسبة للبعض أمر في غاية الصعوبة وخاصة عندما يتعلق الأمر بالصراصير والنمل والبراغيث وبق الفراش والفئران وغيرها من الآفات المنزلية التي تنتشر بكل سهولة في كل أركان المنزل. لكن يُمكنك مكافحة حشرات المنزل بطرق بسيطة وفعالة بشكل نهائي ولن تحتاج إلى المركبات الكيميائية القوية الموجودة في الأسواق المحلية والتي قدد تكون أكثر ضررًا عليك وعلى عائلتك
    شركة مكافحة حشرات بخميس مشيط
    تعتبر مشكلة تسرّب المياه من المشاكل التي تؤرق الأفراد بشكل كبير؛ وذلك لما تُلحقه من ضرر بالمباني والمنازل، لذلك لا بد من السعي الدؤوب للكشف عما إذا كان هناك تسريب مائي أم لا. ويُعرف تسريب المياه بأنّه خلل يطرأ على توصيلات المياه بمختلف أشكالها، سواء كان ذلك في مواسير الصرف أو أكواعها أو مختلف أجزاء مواسير المياه، ومنها: الحنفيات، والخزانات، والسخانات، فيتسبب ذلك الخلل بخروج المياه من المسار المحدد لها إلى محيط المواسير فتتجمع المياه بالقرب من الأماكن المحيطة بالتسريب كالأرضيات والجدران فتلحق الضرر بها نتيجة تفاعلها مع مواد البناء، وتآكل الحديد وتهالك الخرسانة، وبالتالي تفاقم المشاكل في حال التغاضي عن علاجها.
    شركة كشف تسربات المياه بخميس مشيط

    ReplyDelete
  26. https://coub.com/jack.media
    https://pastebin.com/u/jackmedia

    ReplyDelete
  27. nice blog but right now i am seeking to hire someone to do my online exam

    ReplyDelete
  28. The review critiques Peter Jackson's adaptation of 'The Hobbit,' noting a departure from J.R.R. Tolkien's original whimsical tone. It highlights concerns about unnecessary additions, darker themes, and prolonged scenes, questioning the balance of the narrative. The inclusion of new characters, like Tauriel, is acknowledged, while the critique touches on the overuse of familiar characters like Legolas. Overall, the commentary suggests a shift from the simplicity of Tolkien's work to a more complex cinematic portrayal.

    astina333

    ReplyDelete

Search